BetterU

App of the month
TED by TED Conferences
![]() |
Ask the docDr. Davis Smith is an internist practicing in Connecticut and at Trinity College in Hartford. He specializes in the care of adolescents and GLBTQ patients. |
---|
“Is marijuana really better for our health than cigarettes are?”
—Kristina M.*, Western Illinois University (*name changed)
To be clear: We’re comparing two unhealthy behaviors. People are more likely to maintain their health if they don’t smoke anything at all.
But if we’re talking about what’s “better,” we need to know exactly what we’re comparing. People consume marijuana in many different ways, and the source of marijuana matters. For example, as marijuana becomes legalized in more states, the concern about “adulterants,” other substances or chemicals that may be added to increase volume when sold on the black market, probably goes down.
To answer your question, we’ll compare the most similar products: a hand-rolled tobacco cigarette and a hand-rolled marijuana cigarette (joint).
The harm from one inhalation or toke is probably about equal.
Both are inhaled. This means that multiple harmful chemicals (both from the rolling paper and the leaf/bud) are taken into the lungs. The difference is that people tend to consume significantly more inhalations of tobacco than marijuana, so they likely inhale more times from a tobacco cigarette and they likely smoke more tobacco cigarettes in a day. Effectively, that can add up to more harm from tobacco cigarettes.
A filtered cigarette provides some protection compared to an unfiltered hand-rolled smoke, but it’s not exactly healthy.
So what about using some type of filter—for example, smoking from a bowl or bong, or using a vaporizer? Here it gets complicated very quickly. We can make fairly reliable comparisons between different commercial cigarettes (how does this brand stack up against that one?), but it’s very difficult to compare one bag of weed to another, much less compare a bag of weed to a THC-containing liquid smoked with a vaporizer.
Fundamentally, inhaling anything other than fresh country air is potentially harmful.
It is reasonable to assume there is a dose-dependent relationship. In other words, the more harmful substances you inhale, the worse for you. Of course, less of a more-harmful substance may do more damage than more of a less-harmful substance. For example, one inhalation of a marijuana cigarette adulterated with chemicals would likely be more harmful than several inhalations of a similar marijuana cigarette without chemicals.
Both tobacco and marijuana can trigger the reward center in susceptible brains and lead people to continue to use, despite the health, social, financial, or other complications.
Also, we can’t ignore the risks of any kind of exposure to either nicotine or marijuana.
In the end, I can’t really tell you which is better, because I’m not certain what we’re comparing. The less you consume (as measured, I would suggest, by inhalations), the better. The long-term adverse health effects of tobacco are well documented: heart disease, cancer, etc. To date, marijuana is less studied. This is expected to change as legalization advances.
![]() |
Ask the counselorSharon Sevier, PhD, LPC, is chair of the board of directors of the American School Counselor Association. |
---|
“Is it better to sleep it off when you’re going through a tough time?”
—Mark S.*, University of Alaska, Anchorage (*name changed)
Sleep can be a great way to help yourself if you’re sick, but it’s not the best way to cope with tough times. When you’re asleep you’re avoiding your problems, but when you’re awake you can get the support you need from yourself and others. So, how can you take care of yourself in tough times?
Think about possible solutions
You don’t need to act on it right away, but start thinking about what you can do to make the situation better. How can you solve or alleviate the issue? What are the first steps needed to find a solution?
For example, are you having a hard time at school because you are overwhelmed with homework? If so, what are some ways to lighten up your workload? Could you reserve some extra time during the day to catch up? Are there people who could help you? Could you talk to your teachers? Or get a tutor?
Distract yourself
Instead of retreating into bed and under the covers, try to do something else. This may be the perfect time to try something new. Have you been meaning to be physically active again? Go for a walk outside. Being active outdoors can have dramatic positive effects, reducing our stress and increasing our coping ability.
Hang out with your friends
Friends can be the support you need in tough times. You can talk with them openly, and they’ll listen and may have ideas for how to help. Sometimes when we are dealing with tough stuff, it’s a relief to just hang out with our friends and get our minds off it. Those relationships build our resilience.
Take care of yourself
When you’re dealing with a stressful situation, you need to take extra care of yourself. Remember to eat regularly, stay physically active, get enough sleep, and really listen to what your body is telling you. You may need some alone time, and that’s OK—just don’t habitually withdraw.
Stay positive
When you are feeling down, try to remember that this is only temporary. You won’t always feel this way. Take it one hour at a time so that you aren’t overwhelmed. One hour you might be upbeat, the next hour you may feel more discouraged. It’s OK to take the good with the bad—after all, that’s what developing coping skills is all about.
![]() |
Ask the trainerFrankie Romeo is a certified personal trainer, small group training coach, and graduate student at Lipscomb University in Nashville, Tennessee. |
---|
“What exercises could the average student do to eliminate neck pain caused by spending too many hours sitting over a desk? ”
—Amber O., California State University, San Bernardino
Whether we are in class listening to a lecture or at home completing an online assignment, we often have no choice but to sit for long periods of time. In fact, there’s a good chance you’re seated right now. Without moving, analyze your posture: Is your head tilted downward? Are your shoulders slouched forward?
Even if we start from a healthy posture, we tend to relax when our attention is focused elsewhere. This makes it easy to place stress on the posterior muscles of the neck and upper back. I’ve provided four exercises you can perform two to three times each week that help strengthen the muscles linked to neck pain. These can be done inside or outside the gym. Two of the four exercises require an elastic band—an effective, cost-efficient tool for at-home training.
Resisted head extension
- Waffle your hands and place them behind your head toward the top.
- Look up toward the sky, then touch your chin to your chest. This will look like an exaggerated nod.
- The hands behind the head are constantly pulling the head down, forcing the chin towards the chest. Resistance is being applied during the entire movement when moving the head both up and down. This will strengthen the posterior neck muscles, which support your posture.
- Perform 20 slow repetitions.
Lying “T” raise
Perform this movement on a padded surface or carpet to help reduce any discomfort.
- Lie facedown on the floor with your arms straight out, forming a “T,” with your thumbs up.
- Lift your arms and head off the floor. Keep your neck neutral by facing the floor.
- Hold this position for 10–30 seconds. Repeat 3–5 times.
Low straight-arm pull
- Anchor an elastic band around a stable object (e.g., a railing, a piece of playground equipment or furniture, a tree branch). It should be around thigh-height, somewhere between your knee and your hip.
- Stand facing the band with one end in each hand at your sides. Your arms should be straight with no slack in the band. This is the starting position.
- Maintain straight arms and an upright posture as you pull the band slightly behind you. Initiate the movement by squeezing the back and shoulder blades together rather than pulling only at the hands. Step backward or forward as needed to adjust the resistance of the band.
- Perform up to 3 sets of 12–15 repetitions per set.
High elbow rows
- Anchor an elastic band around a stable object (e.g., a railing, a piece of playground equipment or furniture, or a tree branch). It should be around chest height.
- Stand facing it, holding the ends of the band in your hands, with staggered feet—one foot slightly in front of the other.
- Lift your elbows so that your arms form a 90-degree angle with your torso. Maintain this position and an upright posture as you pull with both hands. Make sure to squeeze your back and shoulder blades together.
- Perform up to 4 sets of 8–12 repetitions per set.

Mind your mind
Hope for the haters: How to do self-compassion
By Dr. Holly Rogers
Do you criticize yourself repeatedly? Are you hard on yourself for even small missteps, like leaving your apple core decomposing on the counter or reading the wrong chapter of social psych? If so, you might be a hater. In 2016, make self-compassion your priority.
People who cut themselves more slack are happier, less stressed, and more productive, studies show. Read on for students’ questions on self-compassion. No judgment here.
Q&A Give yourself some loving kindness
Question: How does someone learn self-compassion? I never grew up around it so I don’t really know how.
—Second-year graduate student, Lambton College, Ontario
Answer: Self-compassion is something we learn rather than something we are born with. It takes practice to develop the habit of being kind to yourself. Get started with these steps:
- Pay attention to yourself. Do you feel sick, tired, or stressed? Are you struggling with something?
- Rather than criticizing yourself, think about what you would say to a friend in the same situation. Say that to yourself.
- Give yourself a healthy break: Take a power nap or a hot bath, go to yoga with your roommate, check in with a friend.
Question: How do you stop yourself from judging others?
—First-year graduate student, University of Guelph, Ontario
Answer: The judgment cycle is a hard one to break. With a little bit of effort, you can get a handle on the negativity. Here’s how:
- Spot the judgments: Rather than preventing the thoughts, start by identifying them. Judgments can sometimes be tricky to spot. They include:
- Any thought about liking or not liking something or someone
- Any thought assessing whether something is “good” or “bad,” “right” or “wrong”
- Opinions that masquerade as “facts” (e.g., he’s a loser; anyone who believes that is an idiot)
- Acknowledge the judgment without being critical. Say to yourself: “There’s a judgment,” “Here comes the judge,” or simply “Judgment.” Keep the tone of your acknowledgement light and humorous—no judging your judgments.
- Let the judgment go without buying into it. To let a thought go, simply move your attention elsewhere. If you practice this response to your own thoughts, the judgments eventually start to slow down, leaving more room for happier stuff.
The best way to step up your self-compassion and silence your inner judge is to practice loving-kindness meditation. It’s not as strange as it seems.
Question: What if I’m so stressed I can’t fall asleep or get any work done? My mind is often flooded with negative judgments about myself, especially regarding my ability to complete tasks in the face of anxiety and depression.
—Third-year undergraduate, Wilfred Laurier University, Ontario
Answer: If you are severely stressed or depressed, the self-judgment can be overwhelming, which leads to a cycle of more stress and more criticism. You may need to consult with an expert to find a way through it. As an act of self-compassion, contact your campus counseling center or wellness services and make an appointment. Their support and guidance can help you get back on track.
+ Loving kindness with Koru Mindfulness
Dr. Holly Rogers co-developed the Koru Mindfulness program for college students (currently available on more than 60 campuses in the US). Trials have shown that the Koru program is effective in helping students feel less stressed, better rested, more compassionate, and more mindful. Dr. Rogers is a psychiatrist at Duke University and co-author of Mindfulness for the Next Generation: Helping Emerging Adults Manage Stress and Lead Healthier Lives (Oxford University Press, 2012).

#JobProb
How (and why) to get that internship
In a crowd of applicants, how can you get noticed? How can students demonstrate hands-on, relevant experience? How much does an internship matter to your future employers? Is it possible to make your summer serving ice cream sound like a UN position? Experts reveal all.
Whichever year of college you’re in, it’s not too soon to be thinking about how to position yourself for the job market you’ll face after graduation. The Job Prob, our monthly series, shows you how to use your college years to build the skills, practical experience, and networks that will help you thrive professionally.

Contributor spotlight
Noelle Vuong is a fourth-year nursing student at Humber College in Ontario.
For this issue, Noelle reviewed Fooducate, an app that gives us an insider’s look into the ways the food industry hooks us. It helps us eat healthier by offering an A–D rating for food items, debunking nutrition myths, and enabling users to share recipes.
Why did you join the SH101 Student Advisory Board?
“I joined the SAB to gain a unique experience of working at a health magazine. Each month, I’m amazed at how students across the country keep healthy and active. My favorite part is always the cooking videos, because the recipes are usually right within my budget and time constraints.”
Best productivity tip?
“Take care of yourself. I keep an agenda of how my week is going to play out, and I always leave a big blank space on Saturdays to do literally nothing related to school—like going out with family or friends, seeing a movie, or sleeping in.”
Student reporter internship
+ Info & how to apply
Student advisory board
Selected students from our diverse community of readers help shape SH101 content.
+ 2015 – 16 Student Advisory Board